An Honest 2024 Quince Review by 4 Editors Who Tested Everything


All products and services featured are independently chosen by editors. However, StyleCaster may receive a commission on orders placed through its retail links, and the retailer may receive certain auditable data for accounting purposes.

Sometimes, when a new “It” brand begins popping up everywhere, we can’t help but feel a bit…suspicious. Why is everyone suddenly wearing it? Are the pieces really that good? More than once, we’ve been left feeling disappointed, but in the case of sustainable luxury fashion brand Quince, the clothing and accessories are worth the hype.

We know because we (as in commerce editors and writers at StyleCaster) put them to the test, aiming to give a truly honest review. TL;DR: Quince is quality and worth the money (especially since the items are reasonably priced).

The best things to buy from Quince, at a glance:

What does Quince sell?

In case you haven’t been targeted by social media ads or spotted the pieces in various shopping stories, Quince is essentially a one-stop shop for fashion essentials. A quick browse through the brand’s site and you’ll see that Quince makes clothing for women, men, babies and children, as well as home goods, travel essentials, and luggage. Still, the brand is sure not to overproduce, sticking with classic staples rather than rushing to be on-trend.

Why is Quince so affordable?

Quince lives by one rule: “Quality shouldn’t be a luxury.” The brand, which was founded in 2018, doesn’t believe that only a small group of people should be able to afford well-made items. To prove that it doesn’t need to be this way, it’s transparent when it comes to production costs, breaking it down on the “How It Works” part of its site. In short, it’s a combination of making just the essentials (for low design costs), working directly with factories (including shipping straight from there, reducing its carbon footprint), and having “minimal packaging and corporate overheads.”

Is Quince good?

Quince’s clothing, accessories, and home goods feel like high-end designs despite the low cost. That’s because it uses luxury materials, including Mongolian cashmere, Italian leather, and organic cotton. In terms of a company, it also keeps sustainability in mind, only working with factories that aim to limit their impact on the environment and treat their employees fairly.

Best Quince Clothing & Accessories

Quince item: Cotton Cropped Cable Crew Sweater

Color Options: 4
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: OEKO-TEX Standard 100 100% cotton

“If you’re looking for a cozy sweater with a cropped fit that doesn’t actually feel like a crop top (so confusing), you must get yourself this Quince Cropped Cable Crew Sweater ($50). Let’s start with the material: It feels incredibly luxe. I wore it to work on a rainy day with some linen pants and Docs, and all I needed was a tank underneath to feel nice and toasty in the air-conditioned building. It’s a nice winter-spring fabric — not too heavy, as it is cotton, which makes it on the more lighter side when it comes to sweaters. The cotton fabric is soft, yet durable. The weaving is sturdy, and doesn’t pill easily.

Design-wise, it has a really elegant, classy look that reminds me of a white sweater I used to own from Everlane before I destroyed it by spilling foundation all over it (RIP). To me, it’s very Prep School in that it’s preppy but versatile (especially the color ginger that I’m wearing — it’s so fun and autumnal). And because of the cropped fit, I can wear this with high waist pants or a skirt (or even over a dress), and it’ll accentuate my figure.

Again — it’s really not too boxy or too short, unless maybe if you have a long torso. The sleeves are perfectly long (and I have long arms), which is really important to me because I hate short sleeves on a sweater — like, what’s the point? I do hope Quince adds more colors.”

— Gina Vaynshteyn, Senior Commerce Director

Quince Item: Tencel Jersey Maternity Ruched Dress

Color Options: 3
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: 95% Tencel, 4% spandex

“I underestimated how hard it would be to find affordable, cute maternity clothing. So glad Quince exists, because I’ve been living in a few of their maternity pieces, like this jersey dress. It’s soft, and it’s pill-resistant, which is key because I’ve been rewearing it *a lot*. Because I don’t plan on investing a ton of money into a million different pregnancy outfits, it’s important to me that my maternitywear is high quality, which this is — without breaking the bank.

It’s also pretty flattering (as flattering as a bodycon maternity dress goes, I think), with ruching on the sides and perfect T-shirt sleeves. This has been my go-to ever since my bump really popped!”

— Gina Vaynshteyn, Senior Commerce Director

Quince Item: Responsible Down Puffer Vest

Color Options: 4
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: Shell and Lining: 100% recycled polyester; Fill: 90% goose down, 10% goose feathers

“I initially worried about the Responsible Down Puffer Vest not being warm enough for New York City winter weather, but so far, I’ve been A-OK in temperatures that fall in the 30s and 40s. In fact, I prefer to wear my puffer vest to avoid overheating on the packed subway, so if you run warm, consider getting this lightweight yet still toasty layer.

The removable hood is a standout feature, but I think my favorite part is the fleece-lined pockets that stop my hands from freezing. While I wish they had zippers instead of snap closures, I appreciate how deep they are because I can fit my bulky keys and hand in one pocket, and my phone and other hand in the other. There’s also an interior pocket (with a zipper) that houses my two lip balms and a pair of gloves. All of these storage options have me ditching my purse on most days.

In terms of style, a lot of the puffer vests I’ve been seeing are cropped, so I was excited to find one that’s on the longer side. I’m 5’5” and typically an Extra Small, but I like to size up in outerwear to leave plenty of room for layering. The Small fits me perfectly and has proven to comfortably fit oversized sweatshirts and chunky sweaters underneath.”

— Katie Decker-Jacoby, Associate Commerce Editor

Quince Item: Baby Alpaca-Wool Quarter Zip
Color Options: 5
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: Baby alpaca wool, extra fine merino wool, and nylon

“I’ve been dying to get my hands on a quarter-zip sweater that looks and feels luxurious, and I couldn’t have found a better option than the Baby Alpaca-Wool Quarter Zip. The material is ultra-soft and, best of all, not itchy. While lightweight, it’s actually very warm, plus it’s super versatile and timeless. When I styled it with my Quince puffer vest (pictured above), the outfit felt very “cool rich aunt,” which has me thinking that perhaps I’ve found my new aesthetic. I’ve also worn it with an oversized bomber jacket and puffer coats.

Similar to the Responsible Down Puffer Vest, the Baby Alpaca-Wool Quarter Zip is high-quality yet a fraction of the price of similar styles, which often cost over $100. Hold them up to this $69.90 Quince option and, to me, the decision is obvious.”

— Katie Decker-Jacoby, Associate Commerce Editor

Quince Item: Australian Shearling Mini Boots

Color Options: 3
Size Range: Small
Material: Suede, shearling

“I’ve been wearing these shearling boots for about six months — they warmed my feet through LA’s weirdly cold and rainy spring, were perfect for chilly summer nights by the beach, and are currently keeping me cozy as the temps dip. As someone who has been wearing UGG boots since the 9th grade (I am from SoCal after all), I can confirm these are just as good at half the price. They look and feel like the same thing, and they are truly just as durable. Things I love about them: They’re non-slip, so whether I’m shuffling into the kitchen on my vinyl floors at 6 a.m. or walking my dogs across the slippery grass at the park, these boots have A+ traction. They come pre-water repellent treated so they’ve been able to handle light rain (but I wouldn’t wear them in the snow or during a downpour — and if you want to, I’d apply more water repellent). The suede leather upper and 100 percent Austrailian shearling lining feels luxe. I’m a big fan!”

— Gina Vaynshteyn, Senior Commerce Director

Quince Item: Responsible Down Cropped Puffer Jacket

Color Options: 7
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: Recycled polyester shell, nylon and elastane cuffs, and a fill made off goose down and goose feathers

“I wore this puffer to the San Bernardino mountains last winter and was so impressed by how warm it kept me — chilling winds, snow, and all. Back in LA, where I live, I wore this on cold nights walking my dogs (in 40-degree weather — it gets chilly at night!) and it kept me super snug. As someone who originally dealt with Minnesota winters, I know how stifling a winter jacket can be, and this puffer still gives you enough freedom for movement while keeping you insulated and protected from the elements (thanks to the water-repellent and wind-resistant fabric, you’ll stay dry). The fit is adjustable (hood is removable, bungee drawcord lets you choose how snug you want to be). And the fabric itself feels luxe and is durable. Plus, I like the sleeve thumbholes (a great feature for dog walkers who have to keep at least one of their hands exposed!).”

— Gina Vaynshteyn, Senior Commerce Director

Quince Item: Mongolian Cashmere Knit Hoodie


Color Options: 6
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: 100% Grade-A Mongolian cashmere

“Quince is known for making classic pieces over trendy ones, but this ribbed hoodie brought me straight back to the early ’00s — I even joked on Instagram that it reminded me of something my middle school crushes might have worn (and trust, I mean that as a compliment). Still, I highly doubt the boys back then were rocking Mongolian cashmere, which is what this option is made of. Not only is it super soft, I felt it was warm enough for a (heated) outdoor dinner date, no coat required. Typically, I range between an XS and small in clothing, and the latter gave me the perfect oversized look. I dressed up this typically casual staple with a mini skirt and boots, but prepare to see me styling it with jeans, trousers, and maybe even pajama pants (it’s that cozy).

— Samantha Sutton, Commerce Writer

Quince Item: 100% Organic Cotton Knit Blazer

Color Options: 11
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: 100% organic cotton

“I’m going through a preppy phase, but I’m also a Taurus — I can’t deal with stiff clothing and would rather wear softer, comfortable clothing. Quince’s Organic Cotton Knit Blazer satisfies both needs. On one hand, it looks sleek and really pulls an outfit together, just like a structured option would. However, it’s as soft and flexible as a cardigan or sweater. This might become my new go-to layer!”

— Samantha Sutton, Commerce Writer

Quince Item: Ultra Stretch Ponte Cropped Wide Leg Pant, $49.90
Color Options: 11
Size Range: 0 – 16
Material: Rayon, nylon, and spandex

“You may see trousers in this photo, but what I feel is sweatpants. These super stretchy slacks are the pants for people who hate anything that feels too constricting but still want a sharp, elevated look. The wide leg is roomy and relaxed, but the waist is the real highlight — it’s snug and supportive without feeling too tight (especially after a bloat-inducing meal). I’m also 5’0, so the cropped length is perfect for my short legs — they hit my ankle and no alterations are needed.

To be completely honest, when I first tried them on while working from home, I forgot to change back into my PJs and wore them the whole day through. I can confirm they feel just as comfortable as loungewear but look a lot cuter, and you really can’t beat the price.”

— Samantha Sutton, Commerce Writer

Quince Item: 100% Washed Leather Bomber Jacket, $179.90

Color Options: Black
Size Range: XS – XL
Material: Top grain sheep leather, poly stain

“If you’re obsessed with buying leather jackets like I am, you’ll want to add this bomber option to your collection right away. It’s super sleek looking (if you prefer an oversized fit, I’d recommend sizing up) and extremely comfortable—the leather feels so soft. It hits right at my waist for a very flattering look, and as someone who doesn’t always want to carry a handbag out on the town, I appreciate the two roomy pockets in the front.

No joke, I’ve worn this jacket nearly every day since it arrived, including to the office, on nights out to the bars and even on little errand runs. It’s also surprisingly warm (I’ve been fine layering a long sleeve underneath on 45-degree days in NYC), though I imagine I’ll have to add a puffer on top once the weather really dips.

For the level of quality—the leather used for this jacket is biodegradable and tanned in a Leather Working Group certified tannery—the price is extremely reasonable. If you’ve been searching for a black leather jacket you can wear regularly that won’t cost you hundreds, this is the one.”

— Maya Gandara, Commerce Editor

Best Quince Home Goods

Quince Item: Cotton Velvet Quilt, $180-$230

Color Options: 5
Size Range: Full/Queen, King/Cal King
Material: 100% cotton velvet

“One Quince category to make sure not to overlook is the bedding. This is my second piece of Quince bedding, and I’m once again so impressed. The material feels so incredibly luxe, and it keeps me nice and cozy without making me feel overheated (I’m a hot sleeper, so waking up sweaty is a common occurrence — sorry, TMI!).

I chose the Full/Queen size for my Queen mattress, and it fits perfectly. Not too big so that it hangs awkward, and not too small so that it barely covers the sides and leaves too much of the fitted sheet exposed. It’s not especially plush, so if you’re looking for something very full and thick for harsh winters, this may not be the best bet — but if you prefer a lighter quilt, this is for you.

And it’s definitely a looker. I got Forest Green, and it makes my room look so put together and chic — you honestly can’t even fully see the richness of the shade in the above photo. For the price, you get a quilt that’s made with high-quality materials that feel high quality (and sustainably made — it’s OEKO-TEX® 100 certified and free of harmful chemicals or pesticides), comparable to a brand like Brooklinen or Parachute.”

— Gina Vaynshteyn, Senior Commerce Director

Quince Item: Classic Organic Percale Deluxe Bedding Bundle, $140-$190

Quince Classic Organic Percale Deluxe Bedding Bundle
Quince.

Color Options: 13
Size Range: Twin, Full, Queen, King, California King
Material: 100% organic cotton

“Before moving to New York City a little over two years ago, I plowed through what felt like hundreds of pages of bedding. By the end of my search, Quince was the last one standing. I ultimately went with this brand because of its high-quality make, minimalistic aesthetic, sustainable materials, and price. 

While Quince offers everything from brushed cotton to bamboo bedding, I landed on the Classic Organic Percale Deluxe Bedding Bundle. Why this one? Well, I was sold on the crisp 100 percent organic long-staple cotton and 270 thread count, as the bedding felt super soft and luxurious (and it still does more than two years later). According to the brand, the fabric is best for hot sleepers and warm climates, which makes total sense given the lightweight, breathable feel. The percale has definitely helped me stay cool throughout the night, rather than melting from the radiator. 

This bundle comes in 13 colors and patterns, but I decided on Sand because I didn’t want my room to be all white everything, so going with a lighter neutral shade like this one seemed like a good idea—and it was. The set showed up at my door in the same color I fell in love with on the website and also neatly packed in matching drawstring storage bags (we stan handy and thoughtful packaging!).

As for the brand’s sustainability efforts, Quince’s Classic Organic Percale bedding uses windmill-powered green energy and excludes harsh pesticides, GMOs, and toxins.

Lastly, and perhaps most important if you’re trying to be a smart shopper, is price. Competitors that make percale bedding usually carry sets that only include pillowcases, a fitted sheet, and a flat sheet. I’m not seeing many (or any) besides Quince that also throw in a duvet cover. These kinds of sets (for a Full-sized bed) are made from popular brands, and they’re going for $139, $159, and even $188. Meanwhile, the $140 Classic Organic Percale Deluxe Bedding Bundle includes a duvet cover, a fitted sheet, a flat sheet, two pillowcases, and two shams. The Quince set no doubt offers you more bang for your buck.

If you still have questions about this bedding set, check out my full review.”

— Katie Decker-Jacoby, Associate Commerce Editor



We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

look Nice Care.com
Logo
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart